Summary
Diagnostic excellence depends on clinicians’ ability to develop, test, and revise diagnostic hypotheses—not simply produce polished documentation. This commentary discussed “inference impersonation,” whereby ambient AI scribes imitate reasoning without a way to verify if clinicians independently reasoned through a case. The authors warn that the practice could weaken diagnostic judgment development, and conceal reasoning gaps, recommending independent trainee assessments and competency-based safeguards.
McGaughey S, Abernethy J, Wackett J, et al. When the scribe does the reasoning: ambient artificial intelligence, inference impersonation, and the development of trainees’ clinical judgment. Acad Med. Epub 2026 Sep 15.