09/15/26

When the scribe does the reasoning: ambient artificial intelligence, inference impersonation, and the development of trainees' clinical judgment.

McGaughey, Steven; Abernethy, Jane; Wackett, Jordan; Organick-Lee, John; Jones, R. Logan; Cloutier, Robert L. Acad Med.

Summary

Diagnostic excellence depends on clinicians’ ability to develop, test, and revise diagnostic hypotheses—not simply produce polished documentation. This commentary discussed “inference impersonation,” whereby ambient AI scribes imitate reasoning without a way to verify if clinicians independently reasoned through a case. The authors warn that the practice could weaken diagnostic judgment development, and conceal reasoning gaps, recommending independent trainee assessments and competency-based safeguards.
McGaughey S, Abernethy J, Wackett J, et al. When the scribe does the reasoning: ambient artificial intelligence, inference impersonation, and the development of trainees’ clinical judgment. Acad Med. Epub 2026 Sep 15.